Government
St. Augustine Beach Lowers Pay Range for New City Manager After Amendment 3 Passage
Commissioners also scheduled interviews with the six finalists and planned a public reception where residents can meet the candidates.
By Fabrizio Gowdy

St. Augustine Beach commissioners have agreed to lower the advertised salary range for the city’s next city manager from $160,000-$200,000 annually to $140,000-$170,000.
The change was reached by consensus, rather than through a formal vote, at the commission's Nov. 9 meeting. Commissioners cited the passage of Amendment 3, which slashes non-school property taxes, as the reason for reducing the range.
The salary question had been a point of debate as the city searches for a successor to City Manager Max Royle, who has served in the position since 1989. Commissioner Undine George had previously expressed her concern that the original $160,000-to-$200,000 range was too high. Other commissioners had argued the lower end of the original range was only modestly above Royle’s current $157,000 salary and was necessary to attract quality applicants.
The city is still considering six finalists. It initially selected seven finalists and three alternates from 55 applicants, but St. Augustine Beach Police Chief Daniel Carswell later withdrew from consideration.
Commissioners are planning to conduct Zoom interviews with the finalists on Nov. 19 and 20, which will be recorded and made available to the public. The commission will then decide which applicants they want to invite to the city for in-person interviews, which are scheduled for Dec. 7 and 8.
A public reception with the finalists is planned for Dec. 7. where St. Augustine Beach residents will get an opportunity to meet the candidates.
The city has already conducted basic background checks on the six finalists, scrutinizing their financial and criminal histories, and is also preparing to hire private investigators to conduct more thorough investigations.
It solicited bids from two firms and has received proposals, but has not selected a company. One firm bid $750 per investigation, plus $110 hourly fees for fieldwork and travel. Another bid $5,950 per candidate, plus additional fees for extra reference interviews and work outside the agreed scope. The city does not have a set budget for the private investigation costs.
Commissioners have not set a date to select a new city manager. Royle, whose tenure encompasses the majority of time since the city was incorporated in 1959, has said he is in no hurry to retire and will remain on the job as long as it takes the commission to complete its search.