Government

Pyszczymuka Calls for Stricter In-Person Attendance and Posting Commissioners' Voting Records Online at First Commission Meeting

Pyszczymuka Was Elected Vice Chair Nov. 17 as a Staunchly Slow-Growth Majority Took Control of the County Commission.

By Fabrizio Gowdy

Martin Pyszczymuka

Newly elected Commissioner Martin Pyszczymuka became vice chair of the St. Johns County Board of County Commissioners on Nov. 17 as a slow-growth majority takes firm control of the board.

Commissioner Ann Taylor, another advocate for slowing the county's rapid growth, was elevated from vice chair to chair, replacing commissioner Clay Murphy.

Pyszczymuka used his first meeting on the board to propose several changes intended to make county government more accessible and transparent. He asked staff to explore posting commissioners' voting records online, publishing agendas two Fridays before meetings and occasionally holding evening commission meetings to accommodate those who have work conflicts.

He also asked the county attorney to explore rule changes requiring commissioners to attend meetings in person except in extraordinary circumstances such as illness, military duty or an emergency. The proposal follows several meetings in recent months attended remotely by Pyszczymuka's predecessor, former Commissioner Sarah Arnold.

Pyszczymuka won a four-way race on Aug. 18 with 35% of the vote, defeating Heather Brofford, who had the endorsement of Gov. Ron DeSantis. His election in August helped complete a dramatic shift from just a few years ago, when the board consisted of commissioners who were largely friendly to development.

It began in 2022, when Commissioner Krista Joseph ran on curbing overdevelopment and unseated incumbent Commissioner Jeremiah Blocker despite being outspent 10 to 1. Joseph's upset victory was followed two years later by Taylor and Commissioner Clay Murphy, who also ousted incumbents by running on a slow-growth platform. Murphy has emerged as a bit of a swing vote on development issues, angering some of those who backed him.

But with the election of Pyszczymuka, three board members are now firmly in the slow-growth camp, which means developers seeking approval from the county will likely have a more difficult time.

The commission’s first major land-use decision of Tuesday's meeting was a unanimous denial of an agricultural enclave certification for roughly 36.6 acres at 9400 Byrd Road in Hastings. County staff concluded the property did not meet the state-law requirement that 75% of its perimeter be bordered by qualifying development.

Neighbors of the Hastings property cited flooding, narrow roads and the area’s rural character in urging the board to reject the request.

The board also delayed a request to rezone 5.29 acres on Arapaho Avenue to Commercial Intensive for a proposed outdoor entertainment and gathering venue, modeled after The Block Jax in Jacksonville. Commissioners voted to continue the item until their second meeting in December, seeking more information about preservation of mature trees on the site.

If Tuesday's county commission meeting is any indication, fights over growth and development will continue to be a leading issue for the foreseeable future. St. Johns' population has grown by nearly 75,000 residents since 2020, a 27.4% increase that makes it Florida's fastest-growing county by percentage over that period.