Government
County Commission Reverses Nov. 3 PZA Appointment, Replaces Beth Tate With Krista Dubé
Tate's appointment had upset commissioners who argued the board was passing over the candidate endorsed by the PZA.
By Fabrizio Gowdy

Two weeks after appointing Elizabeth “Beth” Tate to the St. Johns County Planning and Zoning Agency (PZA), the County Commission reversed course Tuesday and voted 3-2 to remove and replace her with Krista Dubé, the candidate previously recommended by the agency.
Commissioner Krista Joseph made the motion to remove Tate and appoint Dubé. Commissioners Ann Taylor seconded the motion and newly-elected Commissioner Martin Pyszczymuka joined them in voting in favor. Commissioners Clay Murphy and Christian Whitehurst were opposed.
The vote undid the commission’s Nov. 3 decision, when the board rejected Dubé in a 3-2 vote before appointing Tate 4-1. Dubé had been recommended in a 6-1 vote by the PZA after the board reviewed 19 applications for the opening. She also had been endorsed by Greg Matovina, the outgoing PZA board member she will now replace.
The PZA reviews development and land-use proposals before forwarding recommendations to the county commission, which has final authority on those matters.
Taylor, the lone commissioner to vote against Tate’s appointment on Nov. 3, said she believed the commission should respect the Planning and Zoning Agency’s recommendation.
“I appreciate that the PZA spent quite a bit of time on the applications,” Taylor said. “When Krista Dubé was recommended by the PZA after consideration, then it comes to our board and we did not support [her], I thought it was very disrespectful to the PZA board.”
But Murphy countered by saying he had "done his homework" and spoken to several PZA members who said they felt torn between Tate and Dubé because both women were well-qualified.
Multiple residents spoke against the reversal, arguing it undermined the board's credibility.
"It's embarrassing, what does a vote mean if it just gets overturned at the next opportunity?" said one speaker. "We don't make all the right decisions the first time, sometimes we make a decision and we gotta live with it."
Others encouraged the board to remove Tate and appoint Dubé.
"It’s my opinion that this commission should respect the opinion of that PZA and take the recommendation,” said Joe McInerney.
Dubé’s term is scheduled to run through Nov. 3, 2030.